Red Dead Redemption

My first playthrough of this game was after playing RDR2 and I think it just makes RDR2 even better because of the story they made with what they were given in this game. While RDR2 is a much more detailed and bigger game than this one, I still was impressed with the size and immersion this game had to offer even after almost 20 years since its release. A lot of the core mechanics and gameplay is similar and the missions/storytelling are fantastic.