Super Smash Bros. Brawl

The Wii was the first console I had growing up so this game holds a lot of nostalgia value to me but even playing the previous two and the ones to come after, this one still did something that the others could not capture. Subspace Emissary was a peak story mode to the game that made every character and scene so epic even with nearly 0 speaking lines. The story was epic, the music was epic, and playing it was epic. And being able to play it with two people made it better because my brother and I could both play and experience this masterpiece together.